GayPatriot

The Internet home for American gay conservatives.

Powered by Genesis

Another Reason to Like Ingmar Bergman

April 24, 2009 by GayPatriotWest

While I find some of the Swedish director Ingmar Bergman‘s films tiresome, I’m always amazed by his capacity to write with light, how he frames a shot and captures an image.

When his movies are good, however, they are brilliant. I recently recounted how Fanny and Alexander moved me. I also find his films Wild Strawberries and Through a Glass Darkly while not as powerful at that flick, they remain meaningful meditations on our relationships to each other and to what lies beyond (or within).

Well, it turns out he wasn’t just a great filmmaker, he also was a champion of freedom, standing up to Swedish authorities who overtaxed him.  When they arrested him for tax evasion,

. . . the director ripped the ever-expanding Swedish government bureaucracy which, he wrote in a letter to the newspaper Expressen, “grows like a galloping cancer” and very publicly decided to abandon the country for West Germany. . . .  As one of his Swedish biographers noted, the Social Democratic press campaign against the director lasted into the late 1980s, after he had returned from exile.

And he didn’t much care for the radical movements of the 1960s.  According to Michael Moynihan at Reason.com, “in his 1988 autobiography The Magic Lantern,” he took issue with student radicals:

It is possible some brave researcher will one day investigate just how much damage was done to our cultural life by the 1968 movement…Today, frustrated revolutionaries still…do not see (and how could they!) that their contribution was a deadly slashing blow at an evolution that must never be separated from its roots. In other countries where varied ideas are allowed to flourish at the same time, tradition and education were not destroyed. Only in China and Sweden were artists and teachers scorned…

Guess it’s time to update my Netflix queue.  And to scoop up a few copies of that book to share with my liberal film-loving friends.

Filed Under: Big Government Follies, Freedom, Great Men, Movies/Film & TV

Comments

  1. sierra says

    April 24, 2009 at 8:13 am - April 24, 2009

    While I don’t judge artists by their politics, it’s worth noting that during Hitler’s ascendency and throughout WW2, Bergman was an ardent Nazi sympathizer from where he lived in neutral Sweden. While Bergman insists revelations over Nazi atrocities changed his mind at the war’s conclusion, the late film critic Richard Grenier asserts that it took Bergman another ten years or so to reverse his stance, apparently harboring the belief that the Holocaust was a hoax.

  2. Julie the Jarhead says

    April 24, 2009 at 10:12 am - April 24, 2009

    My reason to love Ingmar Bergman:

    Bibi Andersson

    (Who also spent a night in jail for tax evasion).

    Miss Andersson is still acting — magnificently. She is also the most beautiful 70-plus year old around today.

  3. ILoveCapitalism says

    April 24, 2009 at 10:14 am - April 24, 2009

    GPW, cool post. There are some Bergman films that I like quite a lot. I hadn’t ever looked into his political history, though. Now I like him that little bit more. Just don’t tell me he was the kind of director who had relationships with 14-year olds. (Just kidding: in the event that he was, of course I’d rather know the truth.)

  4. ILoveCapitalism says

    April 24, 2009 at 10:19 am - April 24, 2009

    Bergman was an ardent Nazi sympathizer

    Aargh, and there we have it. Thank you for the link, sierra.

  5. ILoveCapitalism says

    April 24, 2009 at 10:25 am - April 24, 2009

    It’s interesting:

    …[Bergman] was impressed by the Nazi dictator after seeing him address a rally…
    “Hitler was unbelievably charismatic. He electrified the crowd,” said the Oscar-nominated film-maker. “The Nazism I had seen seemed fun and youthful,”…
    “When the doors to the concentration camps were thrown open, at first I did not want to believe my eyes.”
    “When the truth came out it was a hideous shock for me. In a brutal and violent way I was suddenly ripped of my innocence.”

    I could go with any number of angles on that. It’s an artist-as-political-fool story. It’s a political-fool-having-the-courage-to-admit-the-truth-eventually story. And, given that Nazism was foundationally a movement of the Left, it’s even a bit of a political-fool-is-a-leftist-and-leftists-have-a-strange-fascination-with-brutal-dictators story.

  6. Peter Hughes says

    April 24, 2009 at 11:01 am - April 24, 2009

    #5 – I’ll go with it, ILC. Sounds a lot like The Snob and his own minions (including the sycophantic press) to me.

    Regards,
    Peter H.

Categories

Archives